- "I am sure people need warning of clanky old engines like you, but I am sure your silly rule does not apply to me!"
- ―James being rude to Edward
James Breaks the Rules is a magazine story.
Engines have to whistle when they enter the yards to let the signalman and the workers in the yard know that they are coming - it is the rules. James does not think the rule applies to him and never whistles. One day, whilst returning from the harbour with some trucks, James is switched onto the loop and as a result is late back at the yards. The signalman is sorry for the mistake but James admits he failed to whistle. James is scolded by the Fat Controller and decides that it is best to obey the rules in future.
- This story is very similar to one in the same issue named Henry.